At Santoni’s Marketplace, we believe that the best food is made with heart, right here in our own kitchen. Over the years, we’ve created a wide variety of signature items that have become customer favorites—and we’re always dreaming up new ones! From sweet treats to savory spreads, here’s a closer look at some of the incredible products we’re proud to make in-house.
Let’s start with a classic: our Millhouse Salad Dressing. This creamy, zesty dressing was first created for our signature Millhouse Salad, but it didn’t take long before customers started asking for it by the bottle. Today, it’s one of our most requested items—perfect for salads, sandwiches, or dipping fresh veggies.
If you’ve got a sweet tooth, our Chocolate Topped Cookies and Aunt Jenny’s Devil Cookies are a must-try. The chocolate-topped cookies are a longtime favorite—soft, chewy, and topped with just the right amount of chocolate. But it’s Aunt Jenny’s Devil Cookies that have taken center stage lately. With rich buttery flavor and a surprise toffee crunch, they’ve quickly become our top-selling cookie and a fan favorite at every gathering.
We’ve also been busy creating some fresh pantry staples that customers can’t get enough of—like our house-made Peanut Butters. Available in salted, unsalted, honey, almond and cashew, these are made with just peanuts, almonds and cashews with no other added ingredients. If you’ve ever dipped a strawberry into our store-made Fruit Dip, you already know: it’s dangerously delicious. Made with just a few fresh, simple ingredients, this creamy, slightly sweet dip has become a must-have for fruit platters, lunch boxes, and late-night snacking. Customers tell us they’re hooked after just one bite—and we totally get it. It’s the perfect pairing for berries, apples, grapes… or honestly, just a spoon. Whether you’re entertaining guests or just treating yourself, our fruit dip is a sweet little secret you’ll be glad you discovered.
One of our newest in-house creations is already making a name for itself: Uncle Rick’s Seasoning. Specially crafted for chicken and meats, this blend of herbs and spices is packed with flavor and makes meal prep easy and delicious. It’s quickly becoming a staple in kitchens around the community—and we think it’ll be in yours soon, too.
Of course, we’re still making the items that have kept customers coming back for years—like our famous Cheese Bread, which pairs perfectly with everything from pasta night to Sunday brunch, and our vibrant Rainbow Cakes, a colorful crowd-pleaser for birthdays, celebrations, or just because. And don’t forget our full line of house-made salads—fresh, flavorful, and perfect for lunch, dinner, or your next event.
At Santoni’s, we’re proud to put our name on every item we make in-house. These aren’t just products—they’re part of our story, our traditions, and our promise to bring you food that’s fresh, flavorful, and made with care.
Stop by and taste the difference. You just might find your new favorite!
